Tuesday, October 6, 2009

TEDx Stating the obvious?

Isaac Newton told us that when an apple fell from a tree it invariably headed towards the ground. Noam Chomsky told us we only make sense of the words of another person because we share a knowledge of the basic grammatical structure of language. Such things might seem obvious – especially when presented in a necessarily brief manner to an audience that does not share a common disciplinary background.

I am a social scientist and this means that, in common with others in my discipline, I seek to understand the social world that we all share. We do this through theoretically informed empirical research. So yes - for some people parts or all of my presentation at the recent TEDx might be dismissed as 'trivial', 'uninteresting' or 'boring'. Such critics have every right to hold and broadcast their opinions. However, in so doing they are closing their minds to the possibility of understanding or as Max Weber (another social scientist – but rather more venerable and long dead) put it ‘verstehen’ - by which (broadly) he meant to indicate that human interaction and society is so complex that it may be best understood through detailed description and interpretation. Even if this is 'just to' state the obvious.

It might be maintained that we ‘just get on with’ our interactions across SNSs and so forth. My talk was not of a ‘how to’ kind - as clearly for the audience at these events - Blogs, Twitter, Facebook and so forth are a part of everyday life. Like other social scientists (for example, Erving Goffman and more recently Anthony Giddens to name two) my concern is to ‘get under’ the everyday, the often mundane and taken-for-granted.

Does this matter in our web 2.0 world? Yes - because as social life embraces or (according to some) moves ‘online’ (an old fashioned label to some, including myself) this brings with it all the good and bad aspects of human behaviour. Indeed this shift may enhance or exaggerate and accelerate some forms of behaviour - we have all read reports of ‘cyber’ bullying, relationships damage through SNSs ‘affairs’ and so forth. More pragmatically, an understanding of how and why people move across social media will help in the design of better and sustainable resources. However, the study of such things is still in its infancy and conventional academic work struggles to keep up with the fast pace of change in social media and accompanying research.Thus, the media that you are immersed in and take-for-granted is strange, risky, fast, ephemeral and trivial to most of my academic and commercial colleagues.

My first TEDx proved to be an interesting experience - I’d like to thank my critics for their considered thoughts – I don’t (yet) have a complete answer (but then I’m not as well established, prominent or well-rewarded as the ‘great men’ mentioned above or the other participants at TEDx) - but your responses will feed into my research and the work on my book, ‘Encounters With. Social life in the network society’, in which I am exploring the issues raised in my talk as well as many others in appropriate depth.

For other hot issues on the day and social media noise about TEDxman you might also want to check out the only other female speaker; Sarah Hartley - @foodiesarah

As well as the other attendees and participants,
Louise Bolotin - @louisebolotin

Ian Aspin - @IanAspin

Kim - @Global5ocialite

Ian Forrester
- @cubicgarden

And of course the photos - where one shows me uncannily smiley :-D

14 comments:

Manchester Ted said...

M overall a great event. Really impressed with your performance. Enjoyed it. Thanks!

Anna (from NW) said...

Tweeted you as you were the only other woman there! Nice reply.

Anonymous said...

With thanks from us at TEDx - it was fun and enlightening!

Becka said...

Enjoyed your talk - great take on the scene. Knew you would get a rough reception from some as one of the few woman and brighter than most guys! Nice response - more please.

ManUMan said...

Made my day - insightful and nice to look at too. No wonder a few find you bit of a threat to the usual stuff trotted out on these occasions.

TedBloke said...

OMG some original thinking. Want your book.

ManUJack said...

OMG orignal thinking and from a rose amongst the thorns.

Anonymous said...

Nicly put - as was the presentation. Think some misssed the point. I agree we must attend to the obvious. Too many men rushing to grand gestures IMO - as a woman - all tech and no depth.

AndyK said...

Neatly done. Seriously rate your contribution. Hope to hear more at these kind of events.

MadMe said...

Congratulations Hot talk Hot post Hot chick Opps that might be sexist Well it was Madchester

Louise Bolotin said...

Thanks for the link back and I did appreciate your own comment on my own blog even though we disagree. My name is Bolotin, though, not Bolton!

Dr Mariann Hardey said...

@ All with thanks for your comments. TEDx in my mnid was a great event ! And I want to go to the next one and then the next... and so on.

@ Louise, apologies for the misspelling, this was carelessly cut and pasted by me from another source. Opps. Really enjoyed reading your post too.

@ ManUMan - err thanks. somewhere between being 'trotted out' and 'nice to look at', I appreciate you found it 'insightful' too.

Anonymous said...

Too busy post Ted to get round to a this. My thought is - did I witness the first sighting of a new media star? If I was pitching a related TV, radio or other media series I'd be talking to you - but maybe this has already happened. I'll stay tuned.

Dr Mariann Hardey said...

@ Anon, a fan? Did you get my £'s in the post. Are you after a free drink? No media front row seat yeeeeet. But watch the spaces... I may pop up any time ! :-)